caliallstaring
← All Posts

Canon

Sigma 85mm f/1.2 DG Art vs Canon RF 85mm f/1.2 L (A7 IV vs R6 II): Portrait Blind Test with Rosina

Rosina (@rosinashakirova) and I put two of the fastest 85mm portrait lenses side by side: the Sigma 85mm f/1.2 DG Art on the Sony A7 IV and the Canon RF 85mm f/1.2 L on the Canon R6 II. She wore a purple plaid top with a long dark denim skirt and black boots, which stood out nicely against the fall colors.

Both lenses are at f/1.2 in every pair. For each pose I shot with one camera, switched to the other and shot again from the same spot, so the pose, light and distance match. All photos are JPEGs straight from each camera.

Gear:

The full video is a blind test with all 35 pairs: each pair is shown without names during a 7-second countdown, then the lens is revealed. Below are 16 sample pairs, a mix of close-ups, half body and full length shots. Play along: guess which side is the Sigma and which is the Canon, then tap Reveal cameras.


Autumn Road

We started on a quiet road lined with orange and red fall trees, with leaves piled along the curb. The colorful trees far behind her are a good test of how each lens melts a busy background at f/1.2.

Rosina half body in a plaid top with fall trees behind her on Autumn Road — photo AA
Rosina half body in a plaid top with fall trees behind her on Autumn Road — photo BB

Half body · Sigma f/1.2 · 1/3200s · ISO 100 · Canon f/1.2 · 1/3200s · ISO 200

Rosina full length with hands on her hips on a leaf-covered road — photo AA
Rosina full length with hands on her hips on a leaf-covered road — photo BB

Full length · Sigma f/1.2 · 1/3200s · ISO 100 · Canon f/1.2 · 1/3200s · ISO 200

Window Wall

Next was a red brick wall with white window frames, with the street and yellow trees blurring out behind her.

Rosina half body beside a brick wall with white window frames — photo AA
Rosina half body beside a brick wall with white window frames — photo BB

Half body · Sigma f/1.2 · 1/1000s · ISO 100 · Canon f/1.2 · 1/1250s · ISO 200

Rosina full length walking along a brick wall on a sidewalk covered in leaves — photo AA
Rosina full length walking along a brick wall on a sidewalk covered in leaves — photo BB

Full length · Sigma f/1.2 · 1/1000s · ISO 100 · Canon f/1.2 · 1/1250s · ISO 200

Brick Wall

Leaning on a long brick wall gives strong lines that run off into the blur, which shows how each lens handles the transition from sharp to soft.

Rosina half body leaning against a long brick wall — photo AA
Rosina half body leaning against a long brick wall — photo BB

Half body · Sigma f/1.2 · 1/1000s · ISO 100 · Canon f/1.2 · 1/1250s · ISO 200

Rosina full length leaning on a brick wall with fall leaves on the sidewalk — photo AA
Rosina full length leaning on a brick wall with fall leaves on the sidewalk — photo BB

Full length · Sigma f/1.2 · 1/1000s · ISO 100 · Canon f/1.2 · 1/1250s · ISO 200

Rosina close-up beside a brick wall with long hair over her shoulders — photo AA
Rosina close-up beside a brick wall with long hair over her shoulders — photo BB

Close-up · Sigma f/1.2 · 1/1000s · ISO 100 · Canon f/1.2 · 1/1000s · ISO 200

Canopy Path

Under a big canopy of brown and gold trees the light was soft and even, with a deep, dark background.

Rosina half body looking up with her hands at her collar under a tree canopy — photo AA
Rosina half body looking up with her hands at her collar under a tree canopy — photo BB

Half body · Sigma f/1.2 · 1/2500s · ISO 100 · Canon f/1.2 · 1/2500s · ISO 200

Rosina full length on a path under a tree canopy — photo AA
Rosina full length on a path under a tree canopy — photo BB

Full length · Sigma f/1.2 · 1/2000s · ISO 100 · Canon f/1.2 · 1/2000s · ISO 200

Rosina close-up looking up under the canopy — photo AA
Rosina close-up looking up under the canopy — photo BB

Close-up · Sigma f/1.2 · 1/2500s · ISO 100 · Canon f/1.2 · 1/2500s · ISO 200

White Cardigan

For one set she added a white cardigan over the plaid top.

Rosina half body in a white cardigan holding the collar — photo AA
Rosina half body in a white cardigan holding the collar — photo BB

Half body · Sigma f/1.2 · 1/1600s · ISO 100 · Canon f/1.2 · 1/2500s · ISO 200

Leaf Park

A park covered in fallen leaves, with rows of trees going back into the distance.

Rosina with a hand to her face in a park full of fallen leaves — photo AA
Rosina with a hand to her face in a park full of fallen leaves — photo BB

Close-up · Sigma f/1.2 · 1/2500s · ISO 100 · Canon f/1.2 · 1/2000s · ISO 200

Rosina full length standing on fallen leaves in a park — photo AA
Rosina full length standing on fallen leaves in a park — photo BB

Full length · Sigma f/1.2 · 1/2000s · ISO 100 · Canon f/1.2 · 1/2000s · ISO 200

Rosina looking back over her shoulder in the park — photo AA
Rosina looking back over her shoulder in the park — photo BB

Half body · Sigma f/1.2 · 1/2000s · ISO 100 · Canon f/1.2 · 1/2500s · ISO 200

Red Maple Path

We finished on a path under red Japanese maples beside a black iron fence, the most colorful background of the day.

Rosina half body under red maple trees looking up — photo AA
Rosina half body under red maple trees looking up — photo BB

Half body · Sigma f/1.2 · 1/1250s · ISO 100 · Canon f/1.2 · 1/1600s · ISO 200

Rosina full length on a path under red maples beside an iron fence — photo AA
Rosina full length on a path under red maples beside an iron fence — photo BB

Full length · Sigma f/1.2 · 1/1600s · ISO 100 · Canon f/1.2 · 1/1600s · ISO 200

Want to see all 35 pairs? The full blind test on YouTube goes through every pair with a countdown before each reveal. Keep score and let me know how many you got right in the comments.


Side by Side: What I Noticed

I measured brightness and color on her face in the original JPEGs of all 35 pairs:

  • Same aperture, same blur on paper: both are 85mm f/1.2 lenses, so the aperture is about 71mm wide on both and the depth of field at the same distance is the same. Any difference you see in the background comes from how each lens is designed to render it, not from how much it blurs.
  • Exposure: the Canon was at ISO 200 and the Sony at ISO 100. The shutter speed was the same in 18 pairs, and slightly slower on the Sony in most of the rest. On paper that gives the Canon nearly a stop more exposure, but straight out of camera her face was only about a third of a stop brighter on the Canon (brighter in 25 of 35 pairs). The two bodies just render brightness differently, so for these side-by-sides I evened out the brightness on her face. That way you're judging the lenses, not the exposure.
  • Color: in the 18 pairs where both cameras were at 5900K, neither side was consistently warmer (the Sigma was warmer in 8, the Canon in 10). In the other pairs the Sony was set to 6000K, which makes the Sigma shots look a touch warmer.
  • Framing: I shot from the same spot each time, and her face came out about 3 percent larger in the Canon frames on average. That's a very small difference between two 85mm lenses.

Which one do you like more? Let me know in the comments on the YouTube video above, and tell me how many of the blind test pairs you guessed right.

Shop the Gear

Support

Enjoyed this post?

Every review means renting or buying gear, booking models, and scouting locations. If this helped you make a gear decision, a coffee goes straight toward the next one.

Buy me a coffee

Newsletter

Stay in the loop

Protected by reCAPTCHA. Privacy · Terms

Explore

From the Gallery

View all →
Nikon portraitNikon portraitSony portraitNikon portraitSony portraitSony portrait